hi u guys
2 questions please
can i fall on a 6kn nut/stopper  eg number 4 & 5 size BD nut
if properly placed?
say i lead 2  3 meters out and then take a fall.
would the rock break (considering its a very small crack) or the equipment
question 2 
why is the left (east, left of plattekloof gorge) side of table mountain not very popular for climbing
i never hear of ppl climbing there.
yet the faces do look clean from down below  base of platteklip gorge
many thanks
vernon
6kn nut strength
Re: 6kn nut strength
Yes it should be strong enough. The problem with small nuts are the small surface area that increases the load on the rock. The rock is more likely to break than the nut. Only a tiny bit needs to break out for the nut to fail. If the rock is solid and the placement is good, you should be fine. It goes without saying that you want to be sure you are save. So to give yourself a better change you can do many things, some depend on you, some depend on your belayer and some on gear. With small nuts you want to try placing them deep and spreading the load on as much as possible surface area. Also try to place more than one and if possible equalize them. You also want a belayer that can give you a soft catch. There are lots of other things to reduce the load, but I think you should worry more about the placement, quality of rock and you and your belayer's skill rather than the strength of the nut. Watch E11 (the movie about Dave MaCloud's route called Rhapsody) to see what those small nuts can take (and what not). All being said, I often wondered why BD's small stoppers seem to be inferior to Wild Country in the strength rating department. I like them both though.

 Posts: 1548
 Joined: Fri Dec 15, 2006 12:32 pm
 Real Name: Willem Boshoff
 Location: Cape Town
Re: 6kn nut strength
most new half ropes have a maximum impact force of below 6kn so its actually not possible the exceed the 6kn impact rating of the nut (and the 6kn nut rating is probably conservative).
as shorti said, gear is only as good as the placement. ask him about the 50foot campopping whipper at tafelberg....
as shorti said, gear is only as good as the placement. ask him about the 50foot campopping whipper at tafelberg....
 Nic Le Maitre
 Posts: 1188
 Joined: Mon Apr 02, 2007 9:40 am
 Real Name: Nic Le Maitre
 Location: Stellenbosch
Re: 6kn nut strength
Hi
The rock will break before the nut does, you will struggle to exceed 6kN of force
If you weigh 70kgs and you are 3m above the nut with 10m of rope out from your belayer and you fall then:
The speed that you are falling at is:
Final velocity squared = intial velocity squared + 2 x acceleration x distance
V squared = 0 + 2 x 10 x 6 (The rope begins to stop you after you have fallen 6m)
V squared = 120 m2/s2
V = root of (120)
V = ~11m/s
The rope you are falling on is a dynamic rope and will stretch about 30% of the length between you and your belayer
30% of 13m = ~4m
In order to stop you, you must come to a halt in 4m from a velocity of 11m/s, and now we need to know your deacceleration
Final velocity squared = intial velocity squared + 2 x acceleration x distance
0 = 120 + 2 x a x 4
0 = 120 + 8a
120/8 = a
a = 15 m/s squared
To create this deacceleration a force was required
Force = mass x acceleration
Force = 70 x 15
Force = 1050 N or 1.05kN (don't worry about the minus sign, it merely implies that the force was acting in the opposite direction to your fall, i.e. upwards)
So in order to stop you, a force of 1.05kN was exerted on the nut, about 1/6th of its breaking strain.
As to the second part of your question, there are routes on the faces closer to platteklip, the routes on the ledge are better and cleaner. The old MCSA journals have route descriptions
The rock will break before the nut does, you will struggle to exceed 6kN of force
If you weigh 70kgs and you are 3m above the nut with 10m of rope out from your belayer and you fall then:
The speed that you are falling at is:
Final velocity squared = intial velocity squared + 2 x acceleration x distance
V squared = 0 + 2 x 10 x 6 (The rope begins to stop you after you have fallen 6m)
V squared = 120 m2/s2
V = root of (120)
V = ~11m/s
The rope you are falling on is a dynamic rope and will stretch about 30% of the length between you and your belayer
30% of 13m = ~4m
In order to stop you, you must come to a halt in 4m from a velocity of 11m/s, and now we need to know your deacceleration
Final velocity squared = intial velocity squared + 2 x acceleration x distance
0 = 120 + 2 x a x 4
0 = 120 + 8a
120/8 = a
a = 15 m/s squared
To create this deacceleration a force was required
Force = mass x acceleration
Force = 70 x 15
Force = 1050 N or 1.05kN (don't worry about the minus sign, it merely implies that the force was acting in the opposite direction to your fall, i.e. upwards)
So in order to stop you, a force of 1.05kN was exerted on the nut, about 1/6th of its breaking strain.
As to the second part of your question, there are routes on the faces closer to platteklip, the routes on the ledge are better and cleaner. The old MCSA journals have route descriptions
Happy climbing
Nic
Nic
Re: 6kn nut strength
thanks very much guys for the input
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google Adsense [Bot] and 3 guests